The Hummingbird, Soufrière
Price: $80–$200
Transformed from a colonial mansion into a nine-room, one-cottage retreat, The Hummingbird is perched on a hillside on the edge of town, just steps from a lovely beach frequented by locals. Accommodations are comfortable, with stunning sea and mountain views; seven have private baths. The resort's open-air restaurant is famous all over the island for its French Creole cuisine and views of the Pitons.
Book: The Superior Piton View room, which overlooks the sea and mountains (758-459-7232; nvo.com/pitonresort).
Best for: Those who want a relaxing beach getaway in the heart of a charming Caribbean town.
Rental car: Not required, but recommended for exploring the rest of the island.

U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS

Maho Bay Camps, St. John
Price: Cabins, $135
There's no hot water, and the showers and bathrooms are in communal buildings, but the serenity and sea views at Maho Bay make up for the lack of creature comforts. The roomy platform tents are scattered on a lush hillside and have fans, camp stoves, and welcoming beds; meals in the restaurant are hearty and healthy, and the quiet beaches and calm Caribbean surf are perfect for lazing, swimming, and snorkeling. Ranger-led hikes are offered in the surrounding national park, and at night, a chorus of forest creatures lulls you to sleep.
Book: A tent near the water and away from the parking area (340-715-0501; maho.org).
Best for: Anyone who places value, peace, and beauty above luxury.
Rental car: Not required. A shuttle service provides island tours and transfers to town.

Virgin Islands Campground, St. Thomas
Price: Cabins, $120–$160
A trip to the Caribbean doesn't get any more bare-bones than a stay in the wood-and-canvas tent cabins at the Virgin Islands Campground on Water Island, just off St. Thomas. The white sand beach is ideal for sunning and snorkeling, and the hot tub is a stargazer's delight. The beach bar serves beer and cocktails, but you'll have to cook your own meals (utensils, a grill, and a stove are provided). Those looking for a little nightlife can clean up in the communal showers before heading for the ferry to St. Thomas.
Book: The Suite, a clapboard cottage with a king-size bed that is the campground's version of luxury (340-776-5488; virginislandscamp ground.com).
Best for: Budget-conscious beachcombers who don't mind washing the dishes and making their own beds.
Rental car: Not required.