Conde Nast Traveler Concierge.com

The Eco-Test

Make a Difference with Conde Nast TravelerWith so many Amazon lodges out there, how can conscientious travelers know which are in business for more than a quick buck? Andy Drumm, director of ecotourism for the Nature Conservancy, has worked with indigenous communities and conservation groups for twenty years. "People tend to take a romantic view of the rain forest," he said. "But you shouldn't be afraid to ask hard questions. Not all nature tourism is ecotourism." He suggests that you consider the following:

Does the lodge document its support of conservation? Many lodges only claim to be "green." A sincere lodge will provide evidence. Kapawi Ecolodge & Reserve, for example, supplies a booklet that describes its conservation practices and the local organizations it works with—and includes contact information for verification. Does the lodge employ local people (it should) and, if so, in what capacity? Are they limited to service jobs or do they hold better-paying positions, such as guide? Is there a training system and a way to advance?

How does the lodge interact with local communities? Are tourists simply traipsed through a village while impoverished natives watch, or do the residents benefit in some way, such as by having the opportunity to sell handicrafts? Do the local people participate in lodge decisions that affect their way of life (such as when guest numbers have an impact on subsistence hunting and fishing)?

What happens when you flush? You can learn a lot by asking about a lodge's waste-treatment system. Do toilets flush into a lake or stream? Are dishes washed in the same water? (They were at one "award-winning" lodge, until guests started to get sick.) A lodge that uses, say, composting toilets or a sewage-treatment system is probably paying attention to other critical details.

If the lodge has electricity (and most do), how is it generated? Does fuel have to be hauled in? Petroleum is a toxic chemical, and oil and gas spills can damage ecosystems permanently. Most lodges use a generator, but the best limit their dependency—and risk—by employing alternative sources as well. (And the constant drone of a generator can ruin an otherwise wonderful trip.)

Where did the building materials come from? In general, natural materials are more ecologically sound and aesthetically pleasing than synthetics, and gathering them can provide local employment. But overharvesting plants can disrupt ecosystems; roofing palm is now so depleted in parts of the Ecuadorian Amazon that corrugated metal is more ecologically appropriate.

If You Liked This Article...

More by This Author

Truth In Travel

Condé Nast Traveler is committed to reporting on travel fairly and impartially. We travel anonymously and pay our own way.
more information

E-mail the Editors

Send us your questions or comments about Condé Nast Traveler articles, contests, and features.
e-mail now

Special Offer! Subscribe toCondé Nast Traveler for less than $1 an issue!

Subscribe for one year (12 issues) for only $10..that's a savings of 81% off the newsstand price!*plus applicable sales tax
Full Name
E-mail Address
Address 1
Address 2
City
State
Zip Code
Published in August 2008. Prices and other information were accurate at press time, but are subject to change. Please confirm details with individual establishments before planning your trip.
Traveler Magazine

My Concierge

My Concierge.com

Planning a trip? Start here
  • Save the information you find while researching your next vacation
  • Create a Trip Plan with your favorite hotels, restaurants, and more
  • Upload and share photos with fellow travelers
Join Now Learn More ›

Already a member? Sign In

Advertisement

Advertisement

I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Mobile Terms and Conditions.

Concierge Mobile: Save our travel info to your mobile

I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Mobile Terms and Conditions.

Subscribe to our free RSS feeds:

Get the latest destinations picks, hot hotel lists, travel deals and blog posts automatically added to your newsreader or your personalized homepage.

Learn More ›

Special Advertisement

Contests & Sweepstakes

Omniture events in request: