Cruises That Won't Get You Sick

Scene from my illness-free cruise on Celebrity Cruises' Constellation, February 2007. (Yup, those are my kids . . . again.)
by Wendy Perrin
Can you choose a cruise so as to minimize your chance of catching the gastrointestinal illness known as norovirus? Yes, says this week's edition of industry newsletter Cruise Week. How?
* Cruise any time from June through October.
Norovirus is
seasonal, and there are very few outbreaks in the late spring, summer, and early
fall. Flu season -- especially January and February -- brings the
greatest number of outbreaks.
* Pick a small luxury ship.
Crystal Cruises, Regent Seven Seas, Seabourn, and Silversea have never had norovirus outbreaks. By contrast, within the past five-plus years (Jan. 2002 through May 2007), there have been 23 outbreaks on Holland America, 18 on Princess, 13 on Carnival, 12 on Royal Caribbean, 11 on Celebrity, 10 on Norwegian Cruise Line, 4 on Cunard, and 1 on Disney (way back in 2002), according to Centers for Disease Control records.
Note to anyone concerned about diseases on cruises:
Most cruise ships are so hygienic as to be germophobic -- they take many more measures to prevent the spread of contagious disease than most other 2,000-person environments do -- so, if your wish is for cruise lines to take even more precautions against norovirus, be careful what you wish for!
When I sailed on Celebrity Cruises' Constellation 3 months ago, there were large hand-sanitizer dispensers standing in the middle of hallways (so that everyone would use them upon entering, say, the breakfast room or computer room). After days in port, when we reboarded the ship, crew members sprayed our hands with sanitizer (without asking first). There were announcements over the P.A. system, and in the ship's daily newsletter, advising passengers to avoid shaking hands with anyone in port (a message antithetical to the whole purpose of travel, dontcha think?).
My point: Cruising is an antiseptic form of travel to begin with. Most
passengers stay in an hermetically sealed bubble, seeing ports through the windows of tour buses, eating meals
onboard instead of on shore, and
interacting with few locals other than merchants. Do you really want it to become even more antiseptic than it already is? You can catch norovirus -- or something worse -- in any large hotel, small town, or doctor's office; you just don't hear about it on the evening news, since an infected cruise ship grabs more headlines.















I agree that the antiseptic gel is getting out of hand, but it is a necessary evil since some people just don't understand the importance of washing their hands!
The comic onboard our May cruise did have a great skit with the hand sanitizers though - he had a bottle and and greeted everyone who showed up late for the show with it! Hmmm maybe you had to be there. : 0) LoriB
Posted by: lorib | May 30, 2007 at 07:28 AM