Flying With A Toddler? How Not To Get Kicked Off A Plane

Charlie (then 3), Doug (not yet 2), and me on a transatlantic flight 2 years ago. Note the Sit 'n' Stroll car seat that Doug is sleeping in.
by Wendy Perrin
Last week we learned about the mom and tot who were booted off a plane after the aircraft's flight attendant objected to the 19-month-old's behavior: He kept saying, "Bye-bye, plane" during the flight safety instructions and preparations for takeoff. The mom, Kate Penland, says the flight attendant suggested giving her son Benadryl to quiet him down. "I'm not going to drug my child so you have a pleasant flight," responded Penland. The flight attendant then told the captain that Penland had threatened her. He returned the plane to the gate, and Penland and her son were forced to disembark, even though by then the boy was sound asleep.
The incident has stirred up passionate opinions. There are nearly 2,000 comments about it on MSNBC.com, and loyal Perrin Post readers have added their two cents to Stephan's post "Bozo Flight Attendant Tosses A Toddler."
I've got far too many unanswered questions about this incident to opine on who was right and who was wrong, but I can tell you, as a mother of two preschool boys who were toddlers not long ago (they are now 5 and 3), that there are steps Penland could have taken that likely would have prevented the entire unhappy incident in the first place.
My tips for any parent taking to the skies with an active or fussy (in other words, normal) toddler this summer, when planes are so packed and delays so rampant:
1. Buy your child his own seat on the plane.
Kids under age two can fly for free if they sit in a parent's lap, but most of the one-year-old boys I've observed on planes are far too squirmy to sit happily on a lap in the close confines of an aircraft for a prolonged length of time. In Diane Sawyer's interview with Penland and her son, Garren, on Good Morning America, Garren was "fussy" (Penland's term), wriggling free from her lap, kicking, climbing onto the coffee table, and being such a busy wiggleworm (normal for a child that age) that he was removed from the set by co-anchor Chris Cuomo. Penland told Sawyer that Garren's behavior on the show was similar to how it had been on the plane before they were kicked off. This tells me he would have been better off in his own seat. Once my own sons turned six months old, I found I had absolutely no choice but to buy them their own seats. The reasons for strapping a toddler into his own seat:
*Your tot will fall asleep faster and remain asleep longer.
He can recline in his familiar, comfy car seat that fills the plane seat.
*He can keep his arms and legs moving.
If he's in your lap, he can't. In his own seat, however, he can kick and kick
and kick without touching the seat in front of him.
*You can keep him occupied with games and books.
If
he's on your lap, you're so squished -- especially on a small regional
jet like the one Penland was on -- that it's nearly impossible to lean
down and grab the comfort toys you've stored under the seat in front of
you, and you can't lower the traytable in order to play a game or use a sticker book.

Doug, just turned 3, and Charlie, then 4, on a flight to
Jamaica in January. If a child is in your lap, you can't lower the
traytable, which means you can't put on a video.
2. Carry the right portable car seat that fits into the plane seat.
I always used a Sit 'n' Stroll -- a stroller that contracts into a car seat and expands again into a stroller. Before my youngest son hit 40 pounds, I used it on countless trips where I had to remain mobile, packing around as little gear as possible. Without the car seat, it was impossible to confine my kids on a plane: Whenever they were placed in a large plane seat without it, they easily squirmed out from under their fastened seatbelts.
I know this because I was once in a situation similar to Penland's: Four summers ago I too flew Continental Express out of Houston, alone with then-17-month-old Charlie. For some strange
reason, the flight attendant would not allow me to bring my car seat onto
the small regional jet. (She said it wouldn't fit, which wasn't true. This was the exact same car seat, FAA-certified
for air travel, that Charlie sat in on every other plane he flew from the age of six months to three years.) The result
of having to relinquish Charlie's car seat to the cargo hold? There was no
way to keep him strapped in his seat; the seatbelt couldn't confine him. He spent the flight jumping up and down on the seat -- in turbulence, with the Fasten
Seat Belt sign on -- trying to climb over anyone and everyone to get out. The flight attendant, whom I hope regretted her decision to gate-check the car seat, didn't do or say anything about it.
3. During airport waits, exhaust your child.
Poor Penland and Garren were delayed 11 hours at the airport in Houston. She told one TV news outlet that she said to the flight attendant, "Well, he's been here at the airport for eleven hours, stuck in a stroller, you know, you should be lucky he's not screaming his head off." How much of the delay Garren actually spent "stuck in a stroller" I don't know, but I do know that any parent of an active young child has got to spend as much of their airport time as possible exercising him. The more energy a young boy burns off before the flight, the less squirmy and cranky he will be onboard. Friday's USA Today ran a great list of airports nationwide with kid-friendly areas where you can run your kids before or between flights.
4. Don't feed your tot sugar before or during the flight.
If you must give him fruit juice instead of milk, dilute the juice with water. Obviously, carry non-sugary snacks that your baby can eat onboard.
5. Ease your child's ear pain during the ascent and descent.
You want to keep your child swallowing, and thus prevent his ears from clogging, so give him something to drink during the ascent and descent. You can also alleviate ear pain by giving your tot Infant Tylenol about 40 minutes before lift-off.
6. Do not give your child Benadryl for the first time on a plane.
If you want to do so because that's the only way you and your child can survive a long flight, test it out at home first. At least several days before your flight, give him some Benadryl at bedtime and see if it makes him drowsy. It can easily have the opposite effect and make your kid excitable -- which, of course, is the last thing you want on a plane.
7. Keep your child entertained with toys, games, and books.
When my kids were toddlers, here are the travel-friendly games we brought onboard (and we still do): A MagnaDoodle or travel-size Etch A Sketch; mess-free Crayola Color Wonder paper and markers; Imaginetics magnetic play sets; sticker books; and Colorforms. Sure, a ton of magnetic pieces and Colorforms and markers will end up all over the floor. True, it's a pain in the neck to pick them all up. And yes, at disembarkation you need to wait till everyone else has deplaned before you can begin to clean up your seat area and retrieve all your kids' belongings. But when you fly with small kids, that's par for the course. Last but hardly least, always bring your child's favorite stuffed animal or comfort toy. And don't lose it! Hold onto it as if it were your most prized possession because, with the exception of your child, it is.















Great post, Wendy. You're so right about buying the kid his/her own seat, for all the reasons mentioned plus the fact that it's the safest option. Why some parents would never ride in a car with a child in their lap, but think nothing of "saving a buck" by doing it on a plane, I do not understand.
Posted by: Seafarer | July 17, 2007 at 03:33 PM
Fantastic post and good tips for a soon-to-be-mom. I've definitely saved this one! Thanks!!
Posted by: travelergwen | July 17, 2007 at 04:28 PM
Think long and hard before bringing that favorite toy or doll onboard. I have seen my kids must-haves hit the floor of the airport bathroom, shoved into overheads by overly-zealous stews and "borrowed" and slobbered on by sneezing babies. better to have a spare of the favorite and bring that, leaving the "real" one home. Best choice - many rattles and small animals and dolls are dishwasher or washer/dryer friendly and thus road friendly.
Every Mom's carry-on needs: food & drink. Pay gate area prices if need be, but never be without a full meal, snack, juice/milk and water bottle for each kid; two tennis balls (cheap and fun for waiting area;) books on tape or MP3 and/or kid music selections; kid's hoodie to snuggle into on a cold, noisy plane; mini photo album of parents, friends, pets, fav. teacher; small pillow, washable, for use on the trip - great in rental car. Also change of clothes - spit etc. happens.
Posted by: Gatornan | July 19, 2007 at 03:09 PM
Hi Gatornan,
You suggest leaving your child's "real" comfort toy at home and bringing a "spare" on trips. Funny, I've done the opposite: When my kids were toddlers forming deep attachments to two or three of their stuffed animals, I bought a couple of extras of their favorites and kept them in the closet. So now, should Doug's favorite furry friend get lost, I've got an identical one at home. I also made sure the kids developed attachments to more than one stuffed animal. They each now have three favorites -- and we bring all of them on our trips. If one disappears, we'll still have the other two.
Yeah, we bring tennis balls also! GREAT for exercising the kids in the empty gate area across from the packed one where everybody's waiting for the plane.
Thanks for the tips,
Wendy
Posted by: WendyPerrin | July 19, 2007 at 03:56 PM
There is more to flying with toddlers than keeping them entertained and hoping for good behavior on the plane: there are long lines at busy airports, security checkpoint(s), boarding the plane, sitting in confined space that shakes and makes noise, not to mention puts sometimes incredible pressure on little ones' ears, and travel etiquette issues like not kicking the seats in front... all things that don't get addressed in the usual checklists. How can we as parents expect children to be well behaved - especially when traveling - if they don't know what to expect and what is expected of them?
One answer is the first in the I'm A Good Little Traveler!? Series - the Shae by Air DVD Toolkit?, which has been endorsed in Northwest Airlines' inflight magazine, NWA World Traveler, as well as by USC Childcare Programs, TripConnect, Inside Motherhood, and more. It was filmed from a child's perspective and everything is shot from their height and eye level. The story demonstrates to children what's to come and what their part is. This way instead of being carried/strolled/dragged around blindly, the journey is as exciting as the destination.
There are also books and videos that talk about airplanes (but more how they work, and less what it means to a 2-year-old to travel by air). The best idea is to take a child to the airport before you fly, talk to her about what you'll be doing (standing in that line, putting our shoes and bags through the machine to get their pictures taken, etc.). Also, let her help pack. Shae by Air comes with a picture packing list, which helps involve her in the trip and make it her trip too, not just something she's dragged along on.
More Tips and Tricks can be found at these great sites:
1 - http://www.goodlittletraveler.com/TravelTips.html
2 - http://www.jetwithkids.com/blog
3 - http://www.mytravelingbuddy.com/t_planner_content.shtml
4 - http://www.partnershipforlearning.org/article.asp?ArticleID=1612
5 - http://www.flyingwithkids.com/countdown_checklist.htm
6 - http://takingthekids.com/index.php/main/category/topic/link-o-rama/
As the creator of the Shae by Air DVD Toolkit - the only product on the market today FOR CHILDREN to help prepare them to fly - I am committed to changing the discussion of traveling families from 'how to prepare for (the hell of) flying with kids?' to "How Can We Prepare Our Toddlers To Travel?" - Children, even young children, have the capacity to understand what to expect, what is expected of them, and to play an active role in the journey itself. Shae by Air is available at www.goodlittletraveler.com - and the site is chock full of information, gear, gadgets, tips and tricks, plus travel stories to encourage little adventurers.
Scotty Kober, www.goodlittletraveler.com
Posted by: s2k | November 14, 2007 at 02:19 PM