Conde Nast Traveler Concierge.com

« Breakfast and Bye-byes in Rio | Main | Amazonian Adventure: River Rides and Caipirinhas »

February 26, 2008

Biofuels: The Future of Aviation?

Virginbiofuel_perrinpost
The test pilot takes questions after landing the partially biofuel-powered Virgin Atlantic 747 seen behind him.
Photo: Virgin Atlantic

by Brook Wilkinson

Last Sunday, Virgin Atlantic became the world's first airline to fly using biofuel. Sir Richard Branson would like you to think that this is a great leap toward sustainable air travel. However, it's just not that simple.

I applaud Branson's recent commitment to spend $3 billion on environmentally friendly technologies, but Sunday's test flight from London to Amsterdam didn't prove much. Two studies published just a few weeks ago in the journal Science found that most biofuels actually cause MORE greenhouse gas emissions than fossil fuels. Interested? Read on.

The studies in Science took into consideration the land that is cleared to grow the ingredients for plant-based biofuels, in many cases deforesting the Amazon basin or the jungles of Indonesia. Virgin Atlantic was careful to point out that the babassu and coconut oils in its biofuel came from mature plantations -- but if this fuel were to become widely used, more plantations would undoubtedly have to appear in order to meet demand. Virgin says that they in fact hope to develop an airline biofuel made from algae, so why do this proof-of-concept with a different fuel?

Furthermore, according to Chuck Squatriglia, a blogger over at Conde Nast Traveler's sister publication Wired, the 747 wasn't powered on coconuts alone -- a mere 20 percent of the fuel mix for just one of the plane's four engines was plant-based. Greenpeace U.K. thinks the test flight was a plot to spin positive publicity for that country's airline industry just when environmental activists are protesting the possible construction of a third runway at Heathrow.

Richard Branson, environmental savior or spinmeister? You be the judge.

Comments

"Virgin says that they in fact hope to develop an airline biofuel made from algae, so why do this proof-of-concept with a different fuel?"

Because Branson wanted the publicity of being first. Air NZ is looking at a biofuel test flight later in the year (and yes only one engine at this stage - they want to be sure there are no accidents!). Air NZ has also been checking out algae. For commercial reasons they have not yet announced the exact nature of the biofuel used in the tests.

I forgot to mention that I think Greenpeace is barking up the wrong tree with the distracting attention comment.

Airlines are looking into biofuels for 2 main reasons. (1) PR for trying to reduce reliance on fossil fuels, and (2) if it works they can save a lot of money.

click to post a comment >
Timely and practical travel advice and insights from Condé Nast Traveler's consumer news editor Wendy Perrin. 
Freebies forbidden here! As a Condé Nast Traveler staffer, I accept no payments, gifts, or free/discounted services or products from any travel company. Learn more.
Got a travel question? Visit the Ask Wendy page to post your query and I'll do my best to answer it promptly.
Air Fares and Routes
Air Fare Search
Airline Seat Pros and Cons
Bathrooms Worldwide
Business Travel Advice
ChowHound
Currency Converter
Doctors Overseas
English Newspapers Worldwide
European Hotels
European Road Signs
Flight Arrival Times
Frequent-Flier Mileage Advice
Holidays Around the World
Hotel User Reviews
Priceline Bidding Advice
Travel Health Advice
Arthur Frommer Online
Boarding Area
BootsnAll Travel
Cheapest Destinations (Tim Leffel)
Consumerist
The Cranky Flier
The Cruise Log
The Daily Traveler
Don's Place (Don George)
Ed Perkins (Smarter Travel)
Elliott (Chris Elliott)
Family Travel: See The World With Your Kids
Flyertalk
Freakonomics
Gadling
The Gate
Globorati
Peter Greenberg
Gridskipper
HotelChatter
Hotel Hotsheet
Jaunted
Joe Sent Me (Joe Brancatelli)
Joe Sharkey At Large
Johnny Jet
Killing Batteries
Lonely Planet Travel Blog
The Middle Seat (Scott McCartney)
Rick Steves: Blog Gone Europe
Seat2B (Joe Brancatelli)
This Just In
Today in the Sky
TravBuddy
Travel Savvy Mom
Treehugger
Upgrade: Travel Better
Vagabonding (Rolf Potts)
Vagabondish
Viator Travel Blog
View From the Wing
WorldHum
Published in June 2008. Prices and other information were accurate at press time, but are subject to change. Please confirm details with individual establishments before planning your trip.
Traveler Magazine

My Concierge

My Concierge.com

Planning a trip? Start here
  • Save the information you find while researching your next vacation
  • Create a Trip Plan with your favorite hotels, restaurants, and more
  • Upload and share photos with fellow travelers
Join Now Learn More ›

Already a member? Sign In

Advertisement

Advertisement

Mobile Alerts: Save our travel info to your cell
Submit
Concierge Mobile: Save our travel info to your mobile

Get the latest destinations picks, hot hotel lists, travel deals and blog posts automatically added to your newsreader or your personalized homepage.

Special Advertisement

Contests & Sweepstakes