Guana Island, British Virgin Islands

The tranquility of 850-acre Guana Island, north of Tortola in the British Virgin Islands, makes it the perfect haven for the protected species that call it home—roseate flamingoes, scampering lizards with colorful throat fans, and a handful of raptors. It's a sanctuary for humans, too—especially those smart enough to rent out the whole island. There are four one-to-three bedroom villas with their own private infinity pools and 15 one-bedroom cottages sprinkled over a hill on the north end of the island, all of which take their design cues more from Santorini than nearby Tortola: Look for white walls and light blue shutters.

Guana Island
Tel: 800 544 8262
From $695 per night (island rental $19,585 for up to 32 guests)

Next: A-list estate in Antigua >