Concierge.com's insider take:

Here's a taste of Hamptons hospitality, accompanied by a heaping side of boldface names: A gracious hostess guides you past tables commandeered by the likes of Martha Stewart, Jerry Seinfeld, and Ron Perelman, and a knowledgeable waitress delivers a comforting plate of free-range chicken with roasted vegetables and garlic jus. Granted, if you're not an A-lister, a Friday or Saturday night reservation can be impossible (call one month ahead, starting at 9 am, and be prepared to redial). But if you score a seat, you'll be well taken care of, no matter who you are. During the summer, outdoor tables provide much-needed extra seating, and a pleasantly private back room is less hectic (though also excluded from the celeb spotting). On slower nights—Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday—wood-oven pizzas please the regulars.

Open nightly from 6 pm.