"It's an unspoiled wonderland." The spa on Big Reef Bay uses local ingredients like cactus fiber for exfoliation. A-frame chalets with hammocks have oversize balconies and views of Deadman's Bay Beach that are "truly unbelievable." Deadman's Beach Bar & Grill serves "the best conch fritters I've ever had." The staff and service "are the reasons we keep returning to Peter Island."
(55 rooms)
Also featured on the: Gold List for 2008, Gold List for 2010, Gold List for 2011