Current Time
Currency
Weather
Advertisement
restaurants
Amagansett , New York
11954
Tel: 631 267 7993
Concierge.com's insider take:
On summer weekends, parked cars line Montauk Highway on either side of this Caribbean-style seafood shack. By day, families and older couples dine under umbrellas at tables set with disposable flatware on a gravel-floored courtyard. Menu favorites include spicy, lightly fried squid in a Buffalo-style sauce tempered with blue-cheese dressing and a tasty sandwich of flounder dredged in a garlic-and-pepper batter. As night falls, the roadside shack transforms into a packed pickup joint for tank-top- and flip-flop-clad singles downing rum punch and frozen margaritas. Cyril, with his white beard, funky sunglasses, straw hat, and (if you're lucky) flowing sarong, works the crowd. The bohemian proprietor is quick to accept a drink, but he doesn't accept credit cards—so bring cash or you'll be saddled with his high ATM fee.
Open daily 11 am to 10 pm, mid-April through early October.
User Reviews
write a review ›BEEN HERE? TELL US WHAT YOU THINK
Be the first to write a review of Cyril's Fish House and share your tips with the Concierge.com community.
RSS Feeds